Commented on: The 2020 CrossFit Open National Champions
So good to see our Mongolian Flag within this list :)
Congrats and good luck to our Athletes :) <3
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Matthew Alter
January 10th, 2020 at 4:38 pm
Commented on: The 2020 CrossFit Open National Champions
Why does CF need to recalculate scores to determine National Champions? Makes no sense that Vellner wins the Open but is #2 for Canada. This only happens because scores are recalculated with only Canadian competitors instead of being lifted from the overall placement. If you look at the US men, places 4-7 are all reordered as well.
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Richard Christensen
January 15th, 2020 at 3:22 am
Adler beat Vellner in 3 out of the 5 workouts however in the worldwide rankings the 2 times that Vellner beat Adler, Adler places a lot further down in the rankings.
(edited)
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Matthew Alter
January 17th, 2020 at 9:06 pm
Richard...I'm aware of how the math shakes out. However, my point was and remains that it is improper to recalculate the scores when determining national champions. Recalculating minimizes how MUCH better Vellner was than Adler in those 2 workouts.
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Johnathan Haynes
February 5th, 2020 at 7:39 pm
Thanks for your thoughts, Matthew. The National Champions race is a competition of nationals. Your perspective seems to examine if Adler is fitter than Vellner. There is no re-calculation. Two different competitions are occurring simultaneously. One competition measured all Canadians; another measured every male competitor in the open division. In the context of the world, Vellner was much better than Alder, but the same was not true among Canadians. Both competitions are valuable.
The Open provides a unique opportunity to measure and compare on multiple scales, from one set of tests.
Comments on 200107
5 Comments