\nOnline Courses: Contact us at seminars@crossfit.com \nCrossFit Games Support: Reach out to support@crossfitgames.com \nFor T-Shirt Purchase: Check your inbox for instructions from customer@trackorder.site
\n","orderHistoryHeadlineText":"Order History","orderHistoryLabelText":"Order History","viewOrderDetailsText":"View order details"},"resourcesKickerText":"Resources","rulebookLabelText":"Rulebook","rulebookLinkUrl":"https://games.crossfit.com/rules","preferenceCenter":{"checkAllText":"Check All","emailCommunicationBodyText":"Select which lists you would like to receive communication from","emailCommunicationHeadlineText":"Email Communication","newsletters":[{"bodyText":"Every day since 2001, CrossFit has published a Workout of the Day for new CrossFit athletes, seasoned veterans, and anyone in between. Subscribe to Workout of the Day emails, and you'll receive CrossFit programming in a three-days-on, one-day-off, two-days-on, one-day-off cadence.","brazeGroupId":"d68551b9-ac7e-437e-bfd2-d225702413cc","headlineText":"Workout of the Day"},{"bodyText":"Get inspired with the latest and/or trending articles, stories, videos, and podcasts focused on the CrossFit community and methodology.","brazeGroupId":"1bfd806e-efe3-404d-9980-c8f38c39490b","headlineText":"What's Trending"},{"bodyText":"Be the first to know when official updates and announcements are released from CrossFit HQ.","brazeGroupId":"cb28cb07-ca09-4739-b73b-7413f95a4892","headlineText":"Updates and Announcements from CrossFit HQ"},{"bodyText":"This subscription is for those interested in announcements, updates, and stories about the CrossFit Games season and its competitors. ","brazeGroupId":"e56abfcc-c940-482d-879c-eed93958cbbe","headlineText":"CrossFit Games"},{"bodyText":"This monthly newsletter includes important CrossFit Games competition season updates, resources, and tips. It is intended for competitive athletes but is open to anyone interested in learning more about the CrossFit Games season.","brazeGroupId":"fce49890-9b3c-4e1f-9e06-1bd06cd696a3","headlineText":"The Hopper"},{"bodyText":"The Professional Coach provides a wealth of articles, media, and webinar opportunities that cover all aspects of coaching, including best practices, real-world coaching application, scaling, methodology, nutrition, CEU opportunities, and more. With contributions from experts inside and outside the CrossFit space, this twice-monthly newsletter is the ultimate tool for any coach looking to improve their skills and knowledge. This newsletter is exclusively available to those who hold a Level 1 Certificate or higher. ","brazeGroupId":"653207fb-9734-44c9-a988-23eb18142529","headlineText":"The Professional Coach"},{"bodyText":"The Affiliate Update is a newsletter for CrossFit affiliate owners and includes upcoming event details, business and marketing resources, and general updates from CrossFit HQ. The Affiliate Update is only available to licensees of record (LOR).","brazeGroupId":"1d3e4c63-f03f-4b61-8453-1fbb186ae27e","headlineText":"CrossFit Affiliate Update"},{"bodyText":"An email series for learning what it takes to open and run a successful CrossFit gym","brazeGroupId":"6ab8a53a-167c-4c74-b5ea-3a06cb857068","headlineText":"Interested in Affiliation"},{"bodyText":"CAP is a weekly email available exclusively to affiliate owners that provides comprehensive class plans, resources, and educational tips to help coaches deliver an exceptional experience to their members.","brazeGroupId":"ba7e977e-ec76-41e3-8465-158d38167ed6","headlineText":"CrossFit Affiliate Programming (CAP)"},{"bodyText":"CrossFit Health serves as a vital bridge connecting the realms of fitness and healthcare. Committed to delivering valuable insights, CrossFit Health harnesses the expertise of renowned professionals from the health, wellness, and CrossFit communities. Our mission is to educate individuals on the transformative potential of CrossFit as a powerful lifestyle intervention, ultimately optimizing health outcomes.","brazeGroupId":"a9c5a8a4-df0a-4b0c-acb6-e9b4631fc00c","headlineText":"CrossFit Health"},{"bodyText":"Be the first to know when new products are added to the Official CrossFit Store and receive special offers and discounts conveniently delivered directly to your inbox.","brazeGroupId":"905db0be-a3c8-4f5b-8903-536a04cb0a40","headlineText":"The CrossFit Store"},{"bodyText":"This subscription is for companies interested in on-site event activations and vendor booths at the CrossFit Games and other events hosted by CrossFit.","brazeGroupId":"92fa7fe8-262a-4d6a-9b0d-9fcc8cc17e7d","headlineText":"Interested in On-Site Event Activations / Vendor Booths"},{"bodyText":"Get alerted for upcoming courses. CrossFit courses and certifications are open to individuals and trainers seeking to improve their health and fitness through effective training and nutritional strategies.","brazeGroupId":"dd1ee7a4-2ef5-477b-affb-77347ce81684","headlineText":"Interested in Finding a Course Near You"}],"preferenceCenterHeadlineText":"Newsletter Preferences","preferenceCenterLabelText":"Newsletter Preferences","uncheckAllText":"Uncheck All"}}},"pages":{"breadcrumbs":{"links":[{"text":"Essentials","url":"/essentials"},{"text":"Financial Ties Between Leaders of Influential U.S. Professional Medical Associations and Industry","url":"#"}]},"contentPublishDate":"20200604","contentType":"article","commentTopics":[{"title":"Financial Ties Between Leaders of Influential U.S. Professional Medical Associations and Industry","topicId":"article.20200602145228732"}],"title":"Financial Ties Between Leaders of Influential U.S. Professional Medical Associations and Industry","topicId":"article.20200602145228732","socialMetaData":{"title":"Financial Ties Between Leaders of Influential U.S. Professional Medical Associations and Industry","image":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/04075258/FinancialTies-front.jpg","description":"A 2020 review finds more than three-quarters of those serving on the boards of major medical organizations have received funding from industry. This indication of pervasive conflicts of interest among the leadership of leading U.S. medical organizations reveals the level of industry influence may be substantial."},"categoryLinks":[{"text":"Essentials","url":"/essentials"},{"text":"Science","url":"/essentials/science"}],"cfdailyLinks":[{"text":"200605","url":"/200605"}],"path":"/essentials/financial-ties-between-leaders-of-influential-u-s-professional-medical-associations-and-industry-cross-sectional-study","components":[{"name":"ArticleHeader","props":{"topicId":"article.20200602145228732","date":"20200604","cfdailyLinks":[{"text":"200605","url":"/200605"}],"categoryLinks":[{"text":"Essentials","url":"/essentials"},{"text":"Science","url":"/essentials/science"}],"articleDate":"20200604","authorName":"CrossFit","bylineText":"By","headlineText":"Financial Ties Between Leaders of Influential U.S. Professional Medical Associations and Industry"}},{"name":"TextBlock","props":{"children":"
Question: How common are professional conflicts of interest within the leadership of U.S. professional medical associations?
\n
Takeaway: This 2020 analysis found more than three-quarters of those serving on the boards of prominent professional medical associations received some form of industry funding, with a median annual income of $31,805 from industry.
This 2020 paper reviews the frequency and magnitude of financial ties between the leadership of major U.S. professional medical associations and industry.
\n
Recent research has brought increasing scrutiny of the role of conflicts of interest in medical research, guidance, and practice (1). Sponsored research is more likely to favor the sponsor’s work (2); sponsored education leads to greater prescription of sponsors’ drugs (3); and guideline panels are frequently staffed by individuals with financial conflicts of interest, though these conflicts are rarely fully disclosed (4). Simultaneously, others have argued as much as 20% of health-care spending may be unnecessary or misspent (5). Industry influence may directly contribute to this misspending (6). This paper sought to provide the most comprehensive analysis to date of the extent of the financial conflicts of interest among those serving on the boards of the most influential professional medical organizations in the United States.
\n
Since 2013, the U.S. government has maintained the Open Payments Database, which documents payments between doctors and industry (7). The authors of this paper surveyed U.S.-based doctors to identify the most influential medical organization for each of the 10 costliest medical conditions (in terms of total medical spending). The selected organizations are shown in the table below. Any members of the board of directors, or any other primary governing body as applicable, were considered members of leadership. Notably, this paper only surveyed organizations primarily led by and oriented toward medical doctors and excluded organizations with a substantial advocacy focus like the American Heart Association.
\n
The authors identified 328 leaders across these 10 organizations, 235 of whom (72%) received some payment from industry in the year surveyed (i.e., during their term as a leader), the four years prior, or the year subsequent. The survey indicated 80% of medical doctors had some financial conflict. Payments to these leaders totaled $104.6-129.9 million in research grants, $24.8 million of which was distributed for general payments (speaking, consulting, royalties, etc.) and the remainder for various smaller miscellaneous payments. The median payment received was $31,805.
\n
Table 1: Payments from industry to board members at 10 leading professional medical associations
\n
No organization was entirely free of financial ties, but the financial significance of these conflicts varied greatly. Median payments to leadership of the American College of Physicians and American Psychiatric Association were $404 and $212, respectively. Conversely, median industry payments to leadership of the American Society of Clinical Oncology and American College of Rheumatology averaged $518,000 and $251,000. The share of leadership with conflicts similarly varied from as low as 37% (American Psychiatric Association) to as high as 93% (Infectious Disease Society of America and Orthopedic Trauma Association). The largest recipients of research funding were the leadership of the American Society of Clinical Oncology ($54 million in total) and American College of Cardiology ($21 million in total). Guidelines promoted by these organizations frequently support increased use of health care — a trend that may be directly influenced by these conflicts.
\n
Figure 2: General and research payments to leaders of 10 professional medical associations. General payments include for consultancies, travel, food, and beverages, and royalties. IDSA=Infectious Diseases Society of America; OTA=Orthopaedic Trauma Association; ACC=American College of Cardiology; ACR=American College of Rheumatology; ASCO=American Society of Clinical Oncology; NASS=North American Spine Society; ATS=American Thoracic Society; ES=Endocrine Society; ACP=American College of Physicians; APA=American Psychiatric Association
\n
Previous research has had similar findings. A Japanese study found 87% of the leadership of 19 Japanese medical associations received industry funding (8). A 2014 study found 51% of U.S. medical journal editors received general payments from industry, and 20% received research payments (9). A 2016 study found 87% of U.S. gastroenterologists received industry payments (10).
\n
This study found pervasive conflicts of interest among the leadership of leading U.S. medical organizations, which reveals the level of industry influence may be substantial.
\n","floatPosition":"floatRight","floatWidth":"floatWidthHalf"}},{"name":"Button","props":{"variant":"secondaryBlue","children":"Read the article","url":"https://www.bmj.com/content/369/bmj.m1505"}},{"name":"TextBlock","props":{"children":"\n
\n","hideText":"Hide","status":"active","type":"alert_banner","userCanHide":"no"},"header":{"desktopLinks":[{"below":[{"id":93961,"parent":"93960","target":"_self","text":"What is CrossFit?","url":"/what-is-crossfit"},{"id":93962,"parent":"93960","target":"_self","text":"Find a Gym","url":"/map"}],"id":93960,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Getting Started","url":"/what-is-crossfit"},{"below":[{"id":93964,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"About","url":"/education/about"},{"id":93966,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"Level 1 Certificate Course","url":"/certificate-courses/level-1"},{"id":93965,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"Explore All Courses","url":"/education/explore-courses"},{"id":109033,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"Private Courses","url":"/private-course/"},{"id":109034,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"Military Resources","url":"/army-ignited"},{"id":93967,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"Coaching Resources","url":"/education/resources"}],"id":93963,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Courses","url":"/education/about"},{"below":[{"id":95951,"parent":"93968","target":"_self","text":"Workout of the Day","url":"/wod"},{"id":93969,"parent":"93968","target":"_self","text":"Explore Workouts","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/workout"},{"id":101892,"parent":"93968","target":"_self","text":"Hero Workouts","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/heroes/"},{"id":93970,"parent":"93968","target":"_self","text":"Movements","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/crossfit-movements"}],"id":93968,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Workouts","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/workout"},{"id":93971,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Learn","url":"/media"},{"id":93972,"parent":"0","target":"_blank","text":"Games","url":"https://games.crossfit.com"},{"id":105467,"parent":"0","target":"_blank","text":"Store","url":"https://store.crossfit.com/?utm_source=owned&utm_medium=nav&utm_campaign=main"},{"id":106137,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Open A Gym","url":"/open-crossfit-gym"}],"mobileLinks":[{"text":"Open a CrossFit Gym"},{"text":"Browse","links":[{"below":[{"id":93961,"parent":"93960","target":"_self","text":"What is CrossFit?","url":"/what-is-crossfit"},{"id":93962,"parent":"93960","target":"_self","text":"Find a Gym","url":"/map"}],"id":93960,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Getting Started","url":"/what-is-crossfit"},{"below":[{"id":93964,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"About","url":"/education/about"},{"id":93966,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"Level 1 Certificate Course","url":"/certificate-courses/level-1"},{"id":93965,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"Explore All Courses","url":"/education/explore-courses"},{"id":109033,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"Private Courses","url":"/private-course/"},{"id":109034,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"Military Resources","url":"/army-ignited"},{"id":93967,"parent":"93963","target":"_self","text":"Coaching Resources","url":"/education/resources"}],"id":93963,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Courses","url":"/education/about"},{"below":[{"id":95951,"parent":"93968","target":"_self","text":"Workout of the Day","url":"/wod"},{"id":93969,"parent":"93968","target":"_self","text":"Explore Workouts","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/workout"},{"id":101892,"parent":"93968","target":"_self","text":"Hero Workouts","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/heroes/"},{"id":93970,"parent":"93968","target":"_self","text":"Movements","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/crossfit-movements"}],"id":93968,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Workouts","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/workout"},{"id":93971,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Learn","url":"/media"},{"id":93972,"parent":"0","target":"_blank","text":"Games","url":"https://games.crossfit.com"},{"id":105467,"parent":"0","target":"_blank","text":"Store","url":"https://store.crossfit.com/?utm_source=owned&utm_medium=nav&utm_campaign=main"},{"id":106137,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Open A Gym","url":"/open-crossfit-gym"}]}],"brandLinks":[{"id":93974,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Open a CrossFit Gym","url":"/open-crossfit-gym"}],"loggedInMenu":[{"id":72863,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Manage Account","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/dashboard"},{"id":72864,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Competition Dashboard","url":"https://games.crossfit.com/manage-competition/athlete"}]},"footer":{"mainLinks":[{"below":[{"id":9764,"parent":"511","target":"_self","text":"What Is CrossFit?","url":"/what-is-crossfit"},{"id":9765,"parent":"511","target":"_self","text":"Get Started","url":"/get-started"},{"id":45861,"parent":"511","target":"_self","text":"Workouts","url":"/workout/"},{"id":45862,"parent":"511","target":"_self","text":"Movements","url":"/essentials/movements"},{"id":1741,"parent":"511","target":"_self","text":"FAQ","url":"/faq"},{"id":90183,"parent":"511","target":"_self","text":"Help Center","url":"https://crossfit.my.site.com/Support/s/"},{"id":45103,"parent":"511","target":"_self","text":"Careers","url":"/careers/"}],"id":511,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"About CrossFit","url":"#"},{"below":[{"id":45864,"parent":"45863","target":"_self","text":"Courses Near You","url":"/courses-near-you/"},{"id":45865,"parent":"45863","target":"_self","text":"Certificate Courses","url":"/certificate-courses/"},{"id":45866,"parent":"45863","target":"_self","text":"Certifications","url":"/certifications/"},{"id":45868,"parent":"45863","target":"_self","text":"Online Courses","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/online-courses"}],"id":45863,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Education","url":"#"},{"below":[{"id":45870,"parent":"45871","target":"_self","text":"Open a CrossFit Gym","url":"/open-crossfit-gym"},{"id":45884,"parent":"45871","target":"_self","text":"Field Leaders","url":"/field-leaders"},{"id":90935,"parent":"45871","target":"_self","text":"Global Mentor Program","url":"/global-mentor-program/"},{"id":93982,"parent":"45871","target":"_self","text":"Affiliate Portal","url":"https://affiliate.crossfit.com/tools/"}],"id":45871,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Affiliates","url":"#"},{"below":[{"id":16638,"parent":"45875","target":"_self","text":"Find a Trainer","url":"https://trainerdirectory.crossfit.com/"},{"id":45876,"parent":"45875","target":"_self","text":"Scholarship Program","url":"/scholarship-program-inquiry"},{"id":45877,"parent":"45875","target":"_self","text":"Foundation","url":"/foundation"},{"id":104122,"parent":"45875","target":"_self","text":"CrossFit Medical Society","url":"https://www.crossfitmedicalsociety.com/"}],"id":45875,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Community","url":"#"},{"below":[{"id":45881,"parent":"45879","target":"_self","text":"About the Games","url":"https://games.crossfit.com/"},{"id":45880,"parent":"45879","target":"_self","text":"Leaderboard","url":"https://games.crossfit.com/leaderboard/games/2022?division=2"},{"id":45882,"parent":"45879","target":"_self","text":"Schedule","url":"https://games.crossfit.com/games/schedule?_ga=2.142929340.802559833.1690817966-401013740.1685640771"},{"id":91727,"parent":"45879","target":"_self","text":"Workouts","url":"https://games.crossfit.com/workouts/games/2023"}],"id":45879,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"The CrossFit Games","url":"#"}],"brandLinks":[],"socialLinks":[{"id":66715,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"facebook","url":"https://www.facebook.com/crossfit"},{"id":66716,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"twitter","url":"https://twitter.com/CrossFit"},{"id":66717,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"instagram","url":"https://www.instagram.com/crossfit/"},{"id":66718,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"youtube","url":"https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCtcQ6TPwXAYgZ1Mcl3M1vng"}],"contactLinks":[{"id":531,"target":"_self","text":"Careers","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/jobs"},{"id":532,"target":"_self","text":"Contact Us","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/contact-us"}],"legalLinks":[{"id":533,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Terms & Conditions","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/terms-and-conditions"},{"id":534,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Privacy Policy","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/privacy-policy"},{"id":10717,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Cookie Policy","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/cookie-policy"},{"id":57312,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Disclaimer","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/disclaimer"},{"id":10883,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Contact Us","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/contact-us"},{"id":45883,"parent":"0","target":"_self","text":"Report IP Theft","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/iptheft"}]},"locationPages":{"simpleTiles":{"cards":[{"bodyText":"CrossFit offers a results-based, community-driven approach to functional training that helps you build strength and improve your health—over your lifetime.","headlineText":"Functional Fitness for Everyday Life","icon":{"alt":"Lifting Icon","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/26123658/crossfit-icon-workout-barbell-overhead-press.svg"}},{"bodyText":"Stay motivated with our community of coaches and members, who support your goals through approachable group training classes, helping you stay accountable and excited for each session.","headlineText":"Community Support and Motivation","icon":{"alt":"Heart Icon","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/26123700/crossfit-icon-heart.svg"}},{"bodyText":"Coaches scale class workouts to your fitness level to help you achieve your strength building goals.","headlineText":"Tailored to Your Fitness Levels","icon":{"alt":"Graph Icon","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/26123649/crossfit-icon-levels.svg"}},{"bodyText":"CrossFit coaches are experienced and trained to provide well-rounded and personalized guidance to individuals with varying fitness levels and goals.","headlineText":"Industry Certified Coaches","icon":{"alt":"Certification Icon","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/26123656/crossfit-icon-check-badge.svg"}}],"headlineText":"Build Strength for a Fuller Life"},"gymFinderPromo":{"bodyText":"Contact CrossFit to start your fitness journey. We’ll connect you to the closest gym in your area.","headlineText":"Get Started today","image":{"alt":"Man Lifting Barbell","sizes":{"1536x1536":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/13135656/aa6daff2983e555e3688654515568d25-1-768x512-1.jpeg","1536x1536Height":512,"1536x1536Width":768,"2048x2048":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/13135656/aa6daff2983e555e3688654515568d25-1-768x512-1.jpeg","2048x2048Height":512,"2048x2048Width":768,"hero":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/13135656/aa6daff2983e555e3688654515568d25-1-768x512-1.jpeg","heroHeight":512,"heroWidth":768,"heroLarge":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/13135656/aa6daff2983e555e3688654515568d25-1-768x512-1.jpeg","heroLargeHeight":512,"heroLargeWidth":768,"large":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/13135656/aa6daff2983e555e3688654515568d25-1-768x512-1.jpeg","largeHeight":512,"largeWidth":768,"medium":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/13135656/aa6daff2983e555e3688654515568d25-1-768x512-1.jpeg","mediumHeight":512,"mediumWidth":768,"mediumLarge":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/13135656/aa6daff2983e555e3688654515568d25-1-768x512-1.jpeg","mediumLargeHeight":512,"mediumLargeWidth":768,"small":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/13135656/aa6daff2983e555e3688654515568d25-1-768x512-1-300x200.jpeg","smallHeight":200,"smallWidth":300,"thumbnail":"https://www.crossfit.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/13135656/aa6daff2983e555e3688654515568d25-1-768x512-1-150x150.jpeg","thumbnailHeight":150,"thumbnailWidth":150}},"links":[{"link":{"priority":"primary","text":"Find a Gym","url":"/map"}},{"link":{"priority":"secondary","text":"What Is CrossFit?","url":"/what-is-crossfit"}}]},"locationCourseCards":{"courseLinkText":"Register Now","findCourseLink":{"text":"Find More Courses","url":"https://www.crossfit.com/courses-near-you"},"headerText":"Courses Near You","seminarType":["level-one","level-two"]},"socialSharing":{"facebook":{"description":"Jump into CrossFit in [City Name]! Our certified coach led group training and fitness classes feature strength, conditioning, and functional workouts.","title":"CrossFit Gyms in [State] | Functional Fitness Classes & Group Training"}}}},"user":{},"coachCertifications":{}}
Question: How common are professional conflicts of interest within the leadership of U.S. professional medical associations?
Takeaway: This 2020 analysis found more than three-quarters of those serving on the boards of prominent professional medical associations received some form of industry funding, with a median annual income of $31,805 from industry.
This 2020 paper reviews the frequency and magnitude of financial ties between the leadership of major U.S. professional medical associations and industry.
Recent research has brought increasing scrutiny of the role of conflicts of interest in medical research, guidance, and practice (1). Sponsored research is more likely to favor the sponsor’s work (2); sponsored education leads to greater prescription of sponsors’ drugs (3); and guideline panels are frequently staffed by individuals with financial conflicts of interest, though these conflicts are rarely fully disclosed (4). Simultaneously, others have argued as much as 20% of health-care spending may be unnecessary or misspent (5). Industry influence may directly contribute to this misspending (6). This paper sought to provide the most comprehensive analysis to date of the extent of the financial conflicts of interest among those serving on the boards of the most influential professional medical organizations in the United States.
Since 2013, the U.S. government has maintained the Open Payments Database, which documents payments between doctors and industry (7). The authors of this paper surveyed U.S.-based doctors to identify the most influential medical organization for each of the 10 costliest medical conditions (in terms of total medical spending). The selected organizations are shown in the table below. Any members of the board of directors, or any other primary governing body as applicable, were considered members of leadership. Notably, this paper only surveyed organizations primarily led by and oriented toward medical doctors and excluded organizations with a substantial advocacy focus like the American Heart Association.
The authors identified 328 leaders across these 10 organizations, 235 of whom (72%) received some payment from industry in the year surveyed (i.e., during their term as a leader), the four years prior, or the year subsequent. The survey indicated 80% of medical doctors had some financial conflict. Payments to these leaders totaled $104.6-129.9 million in research grants, $24.8 million of which was distributed for general payments (speaking, consulting, royalties, etc.) and the remainder for various smaller miscellaneous payments. The median payment received was $31,805.
Table 1: Payments from industry to board members at 10 leading professional medical associations
No organization was entirely free of financial ties, but the financial significance of these conflicts varied greatly. Median payments to leadership of the American College of Physicians and American Psychiatric Association were $404 and $212, respectively. Conversely, median industry payments to leadership of the American Society of Clinical Oncology and American College of Rheumatology averaged $518,000 and $251,000. The share of leadership with conflicts similarly varied from as low as 37% (American Psychiatric Association) to as high as 93% (Infectious Disease Society of America and Orthopedic Trauma Association). The largest recipients of research funding were the leadership of the American Society of Clinical Oncology ($54 million in total) and American College of Cardiology ($21 million in total). Guidelines promoted by these organizations frequently support increased use of health care — a trend that may be directly influenced by these conflicts.
Figure 2: General and research payments to leaders of 10 professional medical associations. General payments include for consultancies, travel, food, and beverages, and royalties. IDSA=Infectious Diseases Society of America; OTA=Orthopaedic Trauma Association; ACC=American College of Cardiology; ACR=American College of Rheumatology; ASCO=American Society of Clinical Oncology; NASS=North American Spine Society; ATS=American Thoracic Society; ES=Endocrine Society; ACP=American College of Physicians; APA=American Psychiatric Association
Previous research has had similar findings. A Japanese study found 87% of the leadership of 19 Japanese medical associations received industry funding (8). A 2014 study found 51% of U.S. medical journal editors received general payments from industry, and 20% received research payments (9). A 2016 study found 87% of U.S. gastroenterologists received industry payments (10).
This study found pervasive conflicts of interest among the leadership of leading U.S. medical organizations, which reveals the level of industry influence may be substantial.
Financial Ties Between Leaders of Influential U.S. Professional Medical Associations and Industry