Commented on: The Cardinal Sins of Skewed Research, Part 1: Cloaking
I think that for now science is far from being free and we need to all educate ourself in order to be able to know who is behind the study we are reading. This is the first step to make science free.
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Sam Pat
April 2nd, 2019 at 5:25 pm
Commented on: 190325
Rest
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Andre Freitas
March 26th, 2019 at 6:20 pm
Commented on: 190325
Bem aventurados queles que teme o Thruster.
Blessed are those who fear the Thruster.
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Stacey Carpenter
March 26th, 2019 at 5:32 pm
Commented on: 190325
2mins work 2mins rest
Rotate
Burpee to Squat Jump
and Med Ball OhSq to Wall Ball 14#
total reps 18-19-19 and 15-16-15
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Byron Hills
March 26th, 2019 at 3:13 am
Commented on: 190325
Safety Bar Squats
Sets x reps x weight
3x6x160lb
3x4x180
3x2x200
3x10x140
3x10x120
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Natalie Dennis
March 26th, 2019 at 2:08 am
Commented on: 190325
10RFT
7 box jumps 20”
7 OHS #30
10:30
UNR Crossfit
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Natalie Dennis
March 26th, 2019 at 3:54 am
*#40
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Dezert Sky Kiddoo
March 26th, 2019 at 1:34 am
Commented on: 190325
10RFT
7 box jumps 30”
7 OHS #85
13:48
UNR CrossFit
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Tim Wyatt
March 26th, 2019 at 1:02 am
Commented on: The Cardinal Sins of Skewed Research, Part 1: Cloaking
Ayn Rand said in the expression "free scientific inquiry", "free" is redundant. Apparently not so.
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Bruno Chrisostomo
April 12th, 2019 at 9:33 pm
"Set science free of the rule of the dollar" (Ayn Rand). A requirement to come to the real facts or to establish real/true/pure science.
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Stacey Thompkins
March 25th, 2019 at 9:40 pm
Commented on: 190325
Made up 19.5 results there
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Eric Corlett
March 25th, 2019 at 2:16 pm
Commented on: 190325
rest day = biceps and triceps ;D
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Micah Dodge
March 25th, 2019 at 8:36 am
Commented on: 190325
Well, after a charity event at the weekend, I can barely walk, and need to see a doctor to possibly scan my foot for a fracture. I did 19.5 and stopped after 5 reps. Could i have carried on - yes, should i have? No. For me, a score is just an indication of where I was at on the day. I would have loved to have stuck at it for 20 mins, pushed the envelope, got a "respectable" score, but honestly, even then, in my current state, it wouldn't be a fair representation of my fitness. I only get one body, I train so I can use it effectively in life. Risking longer term injuries for the sake of a number on a scoreboard this week isn't worth it for me. Crossfit has enabled me to lose 55lbs, to maintain that (within general fluctuations), and to live a healthier lifestyle - that includes knowing when to sit out on workouts like this for the greater benefit to my overall health. Good luck to everyone else! do your best, stay sensible, trust the process!
Comment URL copied!
Comment URL copied!
Jeffrey Cain
March 25th, 2019 at 4:52 am
Commented on: 190325
The Cardsharps by Caravaggio offers a valuable insight into the Cardinal Sins of Skewed Research by the Eades.
The Eades’ post concerns scientific misconduct generally and, more specifically, what they term “cloaking:” “the sleight of hand that makes the real money behind a study disappear to the casual observer.”
Caravaggio’s study also offers a portrait of sleight of hand, with the cardsharp furtively cloaking the extra cards in the rear of his waistcoat – his knife at the ready – and unknown to the young aristocrat. Beware of cardsharps, Caravaggio seems to say, they’re among us, and they’re as dangerous as the dagger on the boy’s hip.
What Caravaggio illustrates here is the timelessness of the vice, which is no more particular to cardsharping than it is to academic science. The academic who purposefully conceals her funders is similar to the cardsharp who hides his hand from the unsuspecting youth.
And this, I propose, points to the moral dimension of scientific inquiry. The exercise of science presupposes, like an honest hand of cards, a moral order in which scientists not only seek truth, but also act truthfully. Scientific misconduct is, at root, a moral not a technical problem. I’m afraid that no amount of transparency or oversight boards will weed out immoral acts, including cloaking, in science.
The very nature of scientific inquiry compels a fidelity to truth-telling perhaps like no other enterprise. The thing that CrossFit calls The Mess betrays at its core a long but sure departure from truth-telling at our research universities, public and governmental institutions, and industry. “Let’s start with the truth,” CrossFit Health says. How could science be conducted otherwise?
Comments on 190325
22 Comments